Asset Class: Market and Economic Insights

U.S. midterms: Will a blue wave rock the boat?

U.S. midterm elections typically serve as a referendum on the first two years of a president’s term, often resulting in steep congressional losses for the president’s party. The 2018 election appears to be following a similar pattern, with the Democrats’ lead on a generic congressional ballot peaking in late 2017 when President Trump’s net disapproval rating was also at its highest. However, as the economy has maintained momentum through 2018, President Trump has gained popularity while the Democrats’ prospects have declined modestly.

Midterm elections: Congressional voter intentions track presidential polls

The U.S. House of Representatives tends to have significant turnover in party composition due to the short two-year terms for each member. Republicans currently hold a 23-person majority in the House but will need a strong showing in November to protect that majority. Inputting President Trump’s relatively low 41% average approval rating into a simple regression analysis of first-term presidents’ midterm election results (starting with John F. Kennedy) indicates Republicans are expected to lose 45 seats in the House. Considering they need to hold 23 seats, this analysis suggests the Democrats should be favored to take the House. Further, we think the Democrats’ chances are increased due to the actual results they have posted in special elections over the trailing year, particularly in Republican leaning districts in Pennsylvania, Kansas and Ohio. They have momentum and enthusiasm on their side, which should bring out their voters.

first term presidential midterm election outcomes

Republicans hold a stronger advantage in the Senate, where six-year terms mean fewer seats in play during a given election year. The current composition is 51 Republicans and 49 Democrats (including Independents who caucus with Democrats). However, the 2018 election map favors the GOP, with 26 Democratic seats up for reelection compared to only nine for Republicans. Thus, the odds of Democrats taking the Senate — while certainly realistic — are lower than their House chances.

We do have some concerns regarding a split government, as equity returns tend to underperform during these periods. One theory is that a split government slows down the response to bubbles and crises, as was clear during 2007–2008. However, the U.S. economy is on firm footing over the medium term, so we are less concerned with the composition of the government. Our concern would increase if the economy decelerates, as a sluggish government response would provide more downside.

Election outcomes and expected implications

Split government

Assessed likelihood: High
Expected market implications: Mostly priced in. Democrats will ramp up investigations into President Trump’s actions and strive to thwart his agenda wherever possible. Likely a stalemate for two years as both parties posture into the 2020 elections.

Republican hold

Assessed likelihood: Moderate
Expected market implications: Short-term positive. Potential for further tax reform and continued deregulation. Raises probability of Democrats moving further left in 2020, which would be negative for the U.S. market over the longer term.

Democrat sweep

Assessed likelihood: Moderate
Expected market implications: Short-term negative for the U.S. market and positive for international markets. Democrats will likely push for impeachment, but the necessary two-thirds supermajority in the Senate would make this a high hurdle. Democrats would attempt to blunt some of Trump’s hardline trade policies, particularly with current allies (and likely excluding China). Dollar negative as deficit spending likely to increase further.

Historical returns based on midterm elections

Conclusion

The midterm elections have the potential to shape U.S. policy over the coming years and thus we are watching them closely. However, we do not see the outcome of these elections disrupting the U.S. economy’s strong growth over the medium term and we remain comfortable with an overweight to U.S. equities in our portfolios.

 

Download PDF

Related Articles

Market and Economic Insights Aug 29 BMO Long-Term Capital Market Assumptions
Market and Economic Insights Jul 9 Trade protectionism: Still posturing or landing punches?
Market and Economic Insights Jun 13 Can the U.S. dollar rally continue?

You are now leaving the BMO Global Asset Management web site:

The link you have selected is located on another web site. Please click OK below to leave the BMO Global Asset Management site and proceed to the selected site. BMO Global Asset Management takes no responsibility for the accuracy or factual correctness of any information posted to third party web sites.

Thank you for your interest in BMO Global Asset Management.

You are now leaving the BMO Global Asset Management web site:

The link you have selected is located on another web site. Please click OK below to leave the BMO Global Asset Management site and proceed to the selected site. BMO Global Asset Management takes no responsibility for the accuracy or factual correctness of any information posted to third party web sites.

Thank you for your interest in BMO Global Asset Management.

You are now leaving the BMO Global Asset Management web site:

The link you have selected is located on another web site. Please click OK below to leave the BMO Global Asset Management site and proceed to the selected site. BMO Global Asset Management takes no responsibility for the accuracy or factual correctness of any information posted to third party web sites.

Thank you for your interest in BMO Global Asset Management.

You are now leaving the BMO Global Asset Management web site:

The link you have selected is located on another web site. Please click OK below to leave the BMO Global Asset Management site and proceed to the selected site. BMO Global Asset Management takes no responsibility for the accuracy or factual correctness of any information posted to third party web sites.

Thank you for your interest in BMO Global Asset Management.