Great Southern Coins Review

Disclaimer: We are reader supported.  We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.

Great Southern Coins is a leader in rare coins and precious metals.

If you've ever purchased precious metals through eBay, you might have recognized the company as greatsoutherncoins at Auctions.

The company prides itself on holding a great volume of coins to offer customers.

The company's goal isn't just to provide customers with a great selection of certified and uncertified coins but to provide the best customer service experience that is founded on reliability and honesty.

Before we get started with this review:

We understand how difficult it is to pick a company that you can trust with your hard earned savings.  That's why we create informative and useful information to give you as much knowledge as possible to make the right decision.

We created a list of our highest recommended investment companies, to make comparing and choosing the company best suited to your needs as easy as possible.

Look to see if Great Southern Coins was selected to our "highest recommendation" list this year!


Get a FREE Gold Investing Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:

Protect Your Savings - Tax and Penalty Free!

What is Great Southern Coins?

gsc homepage

Whether you're an avid collector or a bullion trader, Great Southern Coins claims to have a little something for everyone to meet their investing needs.

Their buyers travel all over the country searching for unique investment opportunities through precious metals.

Since they purchase products in volume, Great Southern Coins can give their customers discounts.


Great Southern Coins has several products to meet your investment needs. One product you will find on their website is bullion. Compared to the company's other products, they appear to only carry a small number of bullion products.

At this time, Great Southern Coins is offering a 2022 MS69 American Silver Eagle.  It's uncertain whether they tend to have more bullion product options. However, it's nice to know that they do expand their inventory.


For those interested in jewelry, you'll be happy to find that Great Southern Coins has an extensive selection of jewelry for purchase. You can shop for necklaces, rings, bracelets, and earrings.

The company features J Gowen Jewelry. Gowen is an artisan jeweler and goldsmith who masterfully designs jewelry with quality and honesty.

His pieces are timeless and embody the Texan culture that is captured effortlessly through his great attention to detail and quality workmanship.


Another feature that you'll find on the company's website is Auctions. Great Southern Coins conducts Auctions through its online shop powered by eBay.

Great Southern Coins has sold over 584,000 items with 99.9% positive feedback from customers and 14 thousand followers. 

Great Southern Coins has a very active auction page that's more comprehensive than other precious metal dealers who provide auctions.

For investors specifically looking to hunt down rare coins, you may find that Great Southern Coins is a great option to meet your needs.

Selling to Great Southern Coins

Aside from buying coins from Great Southern Coins, you can also sell to them. Whether you are selling an inherited estate or want to make an upgrade, Great Southern Coins makes it easy for you to do so. 

Since GSC has a wide customer base online and through the store, they can pay higher prices than other dealers. 

GSC also makes the buying and selling process simple. If you are not located near their store in Boerne, Texas, no need to worry. They purchase coins from all over the country. You can also call their toll-free number at 1-888-409-8344 if you have any questions.

Great Southern Coins: Highlights

one gold coin, one penny, two silver coins

There are several highlights of working with Great Southern Coins. Here are a few things to consider:

  • Money Back Guarantee

Great Southern Coins accepts returns with no questions asked. All you need to do is return your coin in a padded envelope within 14 days. A 14-day return period is standard for most dealers.

But what makes GSC stand out is the fact that they cut out the red tape when it comes to the returns process.  The company's "no questions asked" policy means that investors can be sure that they'll be able to return an item for whatever reason.

  • Unique Coins

Another highlight of working with Great Southern Coins for your investment needs is that they practice offering unique coins that you likely won't find anywhere else.

Their wholesalers travel all over the world to secure and curate the best coin collection for their customers.

  • Easy Pricing

When it comes to buying coins, investors want easy access to pricing. Luckily, Great Southern Coins offers transparent pricing on their inventory page.

You won't need to call and ask about how much an item costs, all the information you need is available for your convenience.

  • Trusted Name

Great Southern Coins is a trusted name in the industry. They are an eBay top-rated seller of rare coins and bullion with over 23,000 satisfied customers.

  • Fast Shipping

Depending on your purchase, you will get to take advantage of free, expedited shipping.

  • Option to Request a Coin

If you don't see what you're looking for on their website, all you need to do is request a coin. You can request a coin by calling their toll-free number.

Reviews and Recognitions

Great Southern Coins has garnered several recognitions and reviews. They are included in the Numismatic Association and Nusimastic Guaranty Corporation. GSC is also a BBB-accredited business, verified by Visa, a top-rated seller with eBay, and more. 

Great Southern Coins has also collected several reviews from customers that appear to be more than satisfied with their service. The company has nearly maintained a 5-star rating on Birds Eye with over 300 reviews. 

Some customers said that buying from Great Southern Coins is always a great experience. Another customer said that they always purchase coins from Great Southern Coins and that shipment is always fast and safe.

Other customers have also stated that the company moves quickly and is good at communicating. 

The company has also collected reviews from customers who shop their Auctions on eBay. Many customers have said that they are very honest sellers on eBay. 

Great Southern Coins has collected reviews from customers on Yelp as well. However, these reviews were poor. While there are only 14 reviews, the company received an average rating of 1.0 out of 5.

For this reason, it's important to discuss some of the things that customers have said about the company.  To begin with, many previous customers urged others to be wary of Great Southern Coins.

More specifically, one customer claimed that the company was a deceptive seller on eBay. The customer further stated that Great Southern Coins are providing misinformation regarding the products they offer.

The customer believes that GSC relies on professional photographers to hide the flaws of products.  This same customer stated that GSC tends to claim that a product is uncirculated but when you receive it, the information isn't entirely true. 

Another customer stated that Great Southern Coins mostly offers cleaned coins and that many of their coins are counterfeit.

A different customer also held the same notion that the company buys impaired coins and that they use misleading photography practices to make coins appear a certain way.

Other reviews also state that customers need to be aware of the overstated grading of the coins they sell on eBay. Overall, many customers have expressed that they lost money by purchasing from this company. 

It's also worth noting that more than one customer who left a review stated that their previous negative reviews were getting removed. Great Southern Coins may have more negative reviews than the company is showcasing.

This could also potentially explain why the company has nearly 5 stars on Birdseye and essentially all negative reviews on Yelp, although Yelp is notorious for promoting bad reviews in an effort to get money from business owners to hide bad reviews. 

Due to these discrepancies, it's vital to move forward with caution. While Great Southern Coins has several excellent reviews, it's uncertain how many negative experiences investors have had with the company.

Great Southern Coins: Final Thoughts

Great Southern Coins was established in 2002. They consider themselves the leader in rare coins and precious metals. They have a popular eBay page where they auction off rare coins.

The company is a top-rated seller with a long history of selling products through the platform.  For investors looking for new ways to diversify their portfolio, shopping GSC's inventory could be a great place to start.

Investors will find several products like bullion, proofs, half cents, gold, nickel, dimes, and more.  Great Southern Coins has several highlights like the fact that they offer a large variety of rare coins.

They provide transparent prices and they practice fast shipping.  Great Southern Coins has received several reviews that can be used to make the best decision for your needs.

Through BirdsEye, GSC has achieved nearly 5 stars from around 300 customers. Many of those customers stated that shipping was fast and easy and that buying from the company was a good experience.

With that said, there are a few discrepancies between their reviews. While they've achieved a high rating on BirdsEye, they received an average of 1.0 out of 5 stars on Yelp. 

The reviews from Yelp stated that the company is misleading when it comes to the products they sell. The company tends to use professional photography to hide flaws, which lowers the value of the product.

Customers have also stated that most of their coins are counterfeit.  What's even more interesting is that reviewers have stated that their previous negative reviews were deleted.

As a result, Great Southern Coins likely has more negative reviews than what is shown online.  If you would like to work with Great Southern Coins, it's best to make a small purchase first to gain a first-hand perspective.

Great Southern Coins is a legit company, they are not a scam, but we do not recommend them.  

There are better options for investors looking to make direct purchases of precious metals, and much better options for investors looking to protect their savings with a gold and silver IRA, that we have written about extensively on this website.

You can get a Free Gold Investors Guide from our top gold and precious metals company recommendation by clicking the link above or you can read our article of the top companies we reviewed this year:

>> CLICK HERE to read our list of the Top Gold Investing Companies. <<

Or, if you like what you have read about Great Southern Coins, you can go to their website below: