Goldco vs American Hartford Gold – Which is the Best?

Disclaimer: We are reader supported.  We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.

Goldco and American Hartford Gold are both companies that provide precious metal investment services.

They both offer a variety of gold and silver products, such as coins, bars, and rounds, and may also provide storage solutions for their customers' precious metal investments.

You may be considering these companies, so how do you choose which is the best option?

Well, keep reading as we will describe the important aspects of both companies and tell you which one is the best.

Before we get started:

We understand how difficult it is to pick a company that you can trust with your hard earned savings.  That's why we create informative and useful information to give you as much knowledge as possible to make the right decision.

We created a list of our highest recommended investment companies, to make comparing and choosing the company best suited to your needs as easy as possible.

Look to see if Goldco and American Hartford Gold were selected to our "highest recommendation" list this year!


Get a FREE Gold Investing Packet from Goldco, by clicking the button below:

Protect Your Wealth Today - Tax and Penalty Free!

What is Goldco?

goldco's homepage

Goldco states they are a leader in the precious metals industry. They offer precious metal IRAs and direct purchases of precious metal coins and bars for customers.

Goldco partners with individuals who want to diversify and grow their retirement portfolios safely.  Goldco is a privately held company in Los Angeles with over a decade of experience helping customer secure their retirement savings. 

Additionally, Goldco offers customers precious metals specialists to navigate the process from start to finish, providing a more seamless experience.

What is American Hartford Gold?

american hartford front page of website

American Hartford Gold is committed to helping individuals and families invest in precious metals. The company offers gold, silver, and platinum in coins and bars. 

American Hartford Gold offers physical delivery to your door or in a retirement account, such as a 401K, or TSP. The company states that they provide the highest quality gold and silver coins offered at competitive prices.  

The company has a mission to educate clients about investments in the precious metals industry. They strive to provide customers with unparalleled customer support and transparency.

Goldco Products

Investors interested in precious metals can purchase them with Goldco. The company offers investors an opportunity to buy gold and silver.

The company states that they make it easy for you to get the benefit of owning gold or silver because they believe that precious metals ownership is vital to your retirement portfolio. 

Buying gold or silver with Goldco can be done in three easy steps. The first thing you'll need to do is sign your agreement. The agreement is needed to secure your precious metals purchase and understand how Goldco does business. 

The second step is to fund your account. This allows you to initiate your precious metals purchase. Investors can fund their accounts via a bank wire or you can mail a check to their Los Angeles office.

If you're paying by check, Goldco states that they can send you a FedEx shipping label so you won't pay any shipping costs when expediting your precious metals purchase. 

The last step is to select your precious metals. Once you make your selections, your precious metals will be sent to you. You will also have the option to have your coins sent directly to an insured depository or you may qualify for free storage. 

Goldco offers several types of gold and silver precious metals you can purchase.  Some common ones you'll find on its website include:

  • Silver American Eagle
  • Gold American Eagle
  • Silver American Eagle Proof
  • Gold American Eagle Proof
  • Silver American Bald Eagle

Goldco Services

If you're looking for more than just an option to buy gold or silver, you can also open a gold or silver IRA account with Goldco.  The process to open an IRA account with them involves three seamless steps. 

The first thing you'll need to do is open your IRA account. You can open your precious metals IRA account by signing an agreement to secure your purchase and reviewing their terms of service.

The next thing you'll need to do is fund your self-directed IRA account. You can do this by rolling over your assets from an existing retirement plan like a 401k, TSP, savings, or another IRA account. 

The last step is to purchase your desired precious metals to add to your account.  Goldco offers a relatively simple process to buy precious metals and open a gold IRA account them.

The process seems to be straightforward and transparent and involves just a few short steps.

American Hartford Gold Products

At American Hartford Gold, investors will be able to provide a variety of gold and silver precious metals. On the company's website, you'll find three categories including gold, silver, and IRA-approved coins. 

Like Goldco, American Hartford Gold provides several gold and silver products. Some of the company's IRA-approved gold coins are the Saint Helena Sovereign Gold, Australian Wildlife Gold, Canadian Buffalo, and American Eagle. 

Some IRA-approved silver coins include The Guardian 2oz Silver, Saint Helena Sovereign, Silver, and Australian Wildlife Silver.

American Hartford Gold Services

For investors looking for a gold IRA account, you'll be pleased to know that you can open one with American Hartford Gold.

American Hartford Gold has three simple steps to open an account with them. The first thing you'll need to do is talk with their specialists to get started with all of the necessary paperwork.

Once you've completed all paperwork, the next step is to fund your account. American Hartford Gold states that you could have funds transferred to your new gold IRA account from your existing IRA in as little as three days. 

After the funding process is complete, you'll be able to choose what precious metals you can add to your new account. You can store your newly purchased precious metals in one of their IRA-approved vaults across the country.

Some of their vaults include DDSC in Delaware and various other depository vaults. To learn more about their vault locations, American Hartford Gold requests that you reach out to them for more details.

Goldco Reviews

Goldco has an exceptional rating of 4.8 out of 5 with Consumer Affairs. They have received over a thousand reviews with most customers beings satisfied with working with this company.

Some key things that customers have stated were that Goldco was helpful, ready to do business, and attentive throughout the process.

Customers have also stated that the company was highly responsive and that team members were friendly, adding to a great experience.

American Hartford Gold Reviews

American Hartford Gold has also received exceptional reviews with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 on Consumer Affairs with a little over 50 reviews on the platform.

Customers have stated that the company was very helpful and knowledgeable about precious metals. Customers have also stated that the reps at American Hartford Gold were prompt and that their customer service was exceptional.

When comparing Goldco and American Hartford Gold's reviews, both companies appear to provide an exceptional customer service experience. Customers tend to be satisfied with their precious metals purchases and IRA conversion.

Goldco Recognitions

Goldco has been recognized by several reputable companies. They are a BBB Accredited business with an A+ rating.

They also hold several high consumer review ratings on other platforms like Google Reviews, TrustLink, and Trustpilot.

American Hartford Gold Recognition

American Hartford Gold is also a BBB Accredited Business with an A+ rating and is part of the Business-Consumer Alliance. They also have several high consumer review ratings from other trusted platforms like Trustpilot.

Additionally, they are a 3 times winner of INC 5000 top businesses and have a certified buyback commitment.

Goldco: Advantages and Disadvantages

Let's take a look at the advantages and disadvantages of getting started with Goldco:

  • Advantage: Positive Reviews

One of the best things about Goldco is the company's undeniable positive reviews. Goldco has managed to garner over one thousand reviews through Consumer Affairs, with most customers stating that they have a positive interaction with the company.

Goldco appears to have a solid customer support team filled with knowledgeable team members that are attentive to all of their customers' needs. Whether you're a new or seasoned investor, you will appreciate the service provided by Goldco.

  • Advantage: Wide Selection of Precious Metals

Another benefit of working with Goldco is that they have a nice selection of gold and silver precious metals. For investors looking for variety, you'll find a diverse range of products in their inventory for you to choose from.

  • Advantage: Simple IRA process

Goldco also appears to be among some of the top precious metal companies with a simple IRA process. Investors can open a gold IRA account with them in just three simple steps with the process being online for the most part.

If you want to quickly open a gold IRA to start building your retirement portfolio, Goldco is a great company to get started with.

  • Disadvantage: Their Platinum and Palladium products are not listed on their website.

Something to keep in mind is that the company has limited the products on their website to gold and silver. If you're looking for more options outside of this to diversify your portfolio, you will need to call Goldco directly to learn more about their platinum and palladium products.

American Hartford Gold: Advantages and Disadvantages

Now that we've taken a look at Goldco, here are the advantages and disadvantages of American Hartford Gold:

  • Advantage: Positive Reviews

Like Goldco, American Hartford Gold has been praised with positive reviews by customers. Most customers have stated that the team at American Hartford Gold is responsive and more than willing to help clients with their investment needs.

While American Hartford Gold does not have as many reviews as Goldco, the fact the company's reviews are positive is still worth a positive.

  • Advantage: Great Selection of IRA-Approved Products

Another advantage of American Hartford Gold is that they have a product category section for IRA-approved gold.

This is especially great for investors who are just entering the world of precious metals and want to ensure that they are making the best investment purchases for their needs.

It's also just a convenient way to separate their investor of IRA-Approved gold and silver and other gold and silver products.

  • Advantage: Speak with a Specialists to Start Account Process

American Hartford Gold has a similar process when it comes to opening a gold IRA account with them. The main difference is that investors will need to speak with an IRA specialist first to get started.

While many investors may already know the process of starting a gold IRA account, this aspect of the process is beneficial for new investors.

If you have questions about your account or gold IRAs in general, talking with a specialist can give you the confidence that you need to move forward in the process.

  • Advantage: Buy Back Commitment

American Hartford Gold states that they have a buy back commitment. This commitment states that they will never charge any additional liquidation fees and that clients will enjoy a simple three-step liquidation process.

If you would like to start the process, all you need to do is give them a call, they'll arrange shipment, and then issue you a payment.

  • Disadvantage: No Mention of Fees

American Hartford Gold does not discuss the cost to open a gold IRA account with them. This is information that investors should know before getting started.

Additionally, the company does not feature prices on its inventory page. However, they do provide a link for you to call for pricing.

  • Disadvantage: Limited to Gold and Silver Only

Like Goldco, American Hartford Gold has its limitations. In terms of precious metal coins, investors are limited to gold and silver. They do offer a great number of IRA-approved coins. But, there is no room for diversification beyond this.

If you are looking for additional investment opportunities, you'll need to consider a different precious metals dealer.

Goldco vs American Hartford Gold: Which is Right for You?

Goldco and American Hartford Gold are both excellent choices when it comes to precious metals investing.

Whether you're interested in buying physical precious metals or want to open a gold IRA account, both companies provide options for you to take advantage of. 

Both of these companies have built a positive reputation with 4+ ratings on reputable platforms like Consumer Affairs. Customers have highlighted similar positive things about the company.

For instance, both companies appear to have great customer service, a responsive team and are knowledgeable about precious metal investing.  Things to keep in mind with both companies is that they specifically deal with gold and silver precious metals.

Fortunately, both companies offer a wide range of gold and silver coins. However, if you're looking to expand your portfolio even further, these companies won't have other coins to meet your needs. 

All in all, Goldco and American Hartford Gold are great choices for new and seasoned investors. With their positive reputation, comprehensive service, and wide selection of gold and silver. 

In the end we think Goldco is the clear winner over American Hartford Gold.

While we like both companies, and both companies made our "highest recommendation list", the feedback we have gotten from our readers has been overwhelmingly positive for Goldco.

The great amount of positive feedback from readers, that also matches up with our extensive research, is why we like Goldco the best.

Regardless of which company you choose to partner with, be sure to talk with a representative for further details of their offerings.