Gold IRA vs Physical Gold

Gold IRA vs Physical Gold

Disclaimer: We are reader supported.  We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.

Individuals looking to diversify their retirement portfolios and total assets may find that investing in gold is a wise choice.

Gold is one of the oldest means of trade and is attractive to many investors because it is tangible and distinct from fiat currencies, which many consider more susceptible to inflation. 

In reality, many people buy gold as a possible inflation hedge.

Before we get started with this review:

We understand how difficult it is to pick a company that you can trust with your hard earned savings.  That's why we create informative and useful information to give you as much knowledge as possible to make the right decision.

We created a list of our highest recommended investment companies, to make comparing and choosing the company best suited to your needs as easy as possible.


Get a FREE Gold Investing Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:

gold ira investing information

And now back to the article...

A lesser-known form of IRA allows people to invest in gold, even though many adults typically have one or more IRAs with investments in equities, bonds, or mutual funds.

Seniors wishing to invest in gold may find these self-directed gold IRAs to be a terrific choice.

However, it might be challenging to locate the correct, reliable, unbiased information to determine how to choose between the two due to the rarity of gold IRAs and the IRS's special laws and regulations related to gold investments.  

This article discusses the key elements to consider, whether investing in physical gold directly or through a gold IRA, and the benefits and drawbacks of each.

Investors may choose the best investment by learning about tax advantages and restrictions and what goes into buying and managing gold IRA vs. physical gold.

Gold IRA vs. Physical Gold – What Investors Need to Know

To determine whether to invest in a gold IRA or actual gold, there are several crucial things to understand and consider.

These include each investment's restrictions and possibilities, related IRS rules and tax repercussions, associated expenses, and the investor's duty and available solutions for protecting and maintaining their assets.

Gold IRAs

A gold backed IRA is a specific investment retirement account that allows actual gold and other investment options kinds in place of stocks, bonds, or mutual funds. 

The following are essential things to know about gold IRAs:

  • They can keep alternative investments, such as other precious metals

Gold IRAs can also contain other precious metals, including silver, platinum, and palladium, in addition to gold.

More prominent organizations that provide ordinary IRAs don't offer precious metal IRAs due to the complexity of IRS requirements and paperwork.

  • Gold IRAs are self-directed

A Roth IRA or a standard IRA can both hold gold. Self-directed IRAs demand that participants handle their own funds, unlike regular IRAs.

Investors must choose a custodian or trustee to manage their investments, and they aren't permitted to provide investors with financial guidance.

  • Charges

IRAs have associated costs, but gold IRAs have more since they are physical accounts.

Some gold IRAs contain brokerage fees in addition to the standard starting, yearly, and other transaction fees for IRAs. Most, if not all, charge investors for shipment and storage fees.

  • Tax advantages

One of the main factors influencing how many investors use IRAs is their tax advantages. Like regular IRAs, gold IRAs let investors deduct taxes on their assets.

Traditional IRAs allow investors to postpone paying taxes on income placed into the account until they take the money. Investors with Roth IRAs must pay income taxes upfront rather than at the withdrawal time.

  • Limitations to contributions

The contribution caps for self-directed gold IRAs are the same as those for traditional IRAs. This will increase to $6,000 of earned income annually in 2022, with individuals over 50 being granted an extra $1,000.

Physical Gold

Several types of physical gold are available for purchase, including pure nuggets, jewelry, collector coins, and gold bars.

All kinds of gold have some inherent worth, but bullion, also known as gold bars, is frequently the best option for those considering buying and holding physical gold investments. 

Even so, buying any physical gold may be seen as an investment. Unlike with a gold IRA, investors can purchase and retain gold only to invest, wear it as jewelry, or enjoy the hobby of collecting it.

However, if they want to get the most out of their gold investment, they should be aware that bullion gives the best possibility of getting the most significant return when they sell it and the best chance of quickly finding a buyer. 

Here are a few things investors should keep in mind before investing in physical gold: 

  • When investors sell their gold, they must study gold prices and realize that a profit isn't always assured.
  • Shipping and handling charges apply.
  • The gold must be personally purchased, held, and safely stored (and insured).
  • To purchase from a reliable vendor, investors must conduct some research.
  • They must understand where and how to sell when the time is right.
  • They must also learn about taxes and associated IRS rules.

Why Put Gold in Your IRA?

Individual Retirement Accounts (IRA) protect your retirement as well as your family's financial security.

These special accounts allow you to set aside tax protected savings that you can use in the future.   

With these long term accounts it's important to allocate a significant portion to assets that are solid and reliable, so you have a secure and worry-free retirement. 

a couple listening to a financial advisor

You can have cash in an IRA, but that is devaluing at a rapid pace and inflation is out of control

You need an asset that's dependable, retains it's value, and even increases in value over time, and there is no better asset for this than gold. 

With the world's economy struggling through lockdowns, shortages, wars, and inflation, uncertainty has never been higher and investors are protecting themselves by placing physical gold in IRA's. 

A gold IRA investment prospers from these crisis that negatively affect most other assets. 

Risk is knowing the economic dangers and doing nothing to protect yourself and your family. 

Safety is knowing the economic dangers and taking action to protect your financial future, and this is easy to do with a gold IRA.


The IRS considers any gold a "precious metal" for tax purposes, and all precious metals are considered "collectibles" subject to capital gains tax. Gains made in the short term (sold within a year after acquisition) are taxed at standard income rates.

A capital gains tax equal to an investor's marginal tax rate of up to 28% is applied to long-term gains (assets sold more than a year after purchase), while anybody in a higher tax band still only pays 28% on any gold earnings.

IRS Reporting Requirements

The sale of precious metals is subject to specific reporting requirements by the IRS. Investors who invest in real gold are in charge of adhering to these rules, so they should get familiar with them.

Some particular kinds of gold need reporting at the time of sale, while others can wait until ordinary taxes are submitted. Any tax due from the sale of gold must be paid in addition to their ordinary taxes for that year.

Pros and Cons of Physical Gold vs. Gold IRAs

There are advantages and disadvantages to purchasing real gold, as well as advantages and disadvantages of buying gold IRAs, as outlined below.

  • Pros of Gold IRAs
  • Other precious metals and alternative assets, such as real estate or cryptocurrency, may also be included in a gold IRA. An investor's whole retirement portfolio may be diversified with a gold IRA.
  • The advantages of conventional IRA accounts, such as tax deductions or deferrals, also apply to gold IRAs. However, unlike actual gold, these funds are not taxed at the same capital gains rate as collectibles.
  • Custodians are in charge of reporting documentation and any necessary disbursements.
  • Investments are probably safer than self-storage because custodians must be insured and retain the gold.
  • The best holding strategy for this kind of asset is long-term.
  • Cons of Gold IRAs
  • Gold regarded as collectible by the IRS (like numismatics) is not permitted to be held in an IRA.
  • Fees for gold IRAs are higher than those for gold bars.
  • To purchase the gold and deliver it to their vault, they must select a custodian or trustee.
  • Investors can't access their investments immediately due to custodians and IRA regulations, which might put them in a difficult situation if they suddenly need to withdraw money for an emergency.
  • Custodian storage costs could be more expensive than keeping the gold safe and secure in a bank vault or home safe.
  • Early withdrawals may attract exorbitant fees.
  • Pros of Physical Gold
  • Investors have quick access if they store their gold in the house or other locations with direct, simple access.
  • Compared to a self-directed IRA, investors pay less in associated costs.
  • All of the varieties of gold are available for purchase, providing a more comprehensive range of possible prices.
  • Investors can sell at any time and are not constrained by the timing of gold IRA distributions or early withdrawal costs.
  • Cons of Physical Gold
  • Investors must securely store and insure the gold.
  • Investors must still find trustworthy dealers and purchasers and pay shipping and handling fees. It can be more straightforward to say than to liquidate precious metals outside of a regulated atmosphere.
  • Since the IRA views gold outside of an IRA as a collectible, earnings are treated as capital gains, and sales must be recorded and paid for with that year's taxes.
  • If an investor intends to hold for the long term, physical gold does not give the IRA tax savings that come with such a strategy.

Who Should Invest in a Gold IRA?

The initial step in creating a gold IRA is selecting a provider. These agencies will assist in opening the account, making financial contributions, buying metals, and ensuring the gold and silver are transferred to an authorized depository for safekeeping.  

Gold IRAs may be a suitable investment for investors who:

  • Do you want to profit from IRA tax advantages?
  • Do you want to diversify your portfolio with additional alternative assets like other precious metals, property, or cryptocurrencies?
  • Desire the security of holding gold through an IRA for the long term but are unwilling to pay fees in return for that assurance.
  • Feel confident they can handle the duty of getting a custodian and administering your IRA (it's easier than it sounds).

In certain situations, IRA companies may also serve as account custodians, meaning they'll take care of investors' IRA paperwork and compliance.

Precious metals are a well-liked investment, and several gold IRA companies are available to select from, each with its costs, services, and standards for customer service.

Investors should make thoughtful decisions when starting a gold IRA to guarantee they receive the finest support at the lowest cost.

How Long Does it Take to Open a Gold IRA?

It takes 10 to 15 minutes to finish the gold IRA application procedure. Additionally, the processing is quick, and in most circumstances, your account may be established in only a business day.  

The remainder depends on how quickly investors start financing after that. Transfers and rollovers typically take seven to ten business days if your current account custodian responds quickly.

It could take longer to fund your account with an actual mail check. Potential investors should ask the IRA provider they're considering for estimates particular to their accounts and procedures because timelines might vary per business.

Who Should Invest in Physical Gold?

Private mints, government mints, precious metals merchants, and jewelry stores are options for purchasing gold. Numismatic coins and other gold goods intended for gift-giving and collection should be avoided by investors.

These items are not what the typical gold investor requires and are designed for different purposes. 

It is best to consider selling the gold when deciding where to acquire it. Some companies that deal in gold will also buy it from you. Some will even purchase gold they did not sell but could do so at a lesser price.  

Investors should consider investing in physical gold if they want:

  • More alternatives for the sorts of gold you can invest in.
  • Unrestricted access to your gold, whether you keep it at home for quick access or in a bank's safe deposit box.
  • Freedom from IRA regulations governing when to make withdrawals and distribute funds.
  • To avoid custodian costs for a gold IRA.

Investors need to know that buying actual metal is not the only option to participate in the gold market. Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are top-rated because they are simple to invest in the gold market without owning any gold. 

The ability to buy shares that reflect a certain amount of gold gives investors exposure to the price of the metal through the use of gold exchange-traded funds (ETFs).

Neither that nor the fact that an ETF is backed by genuine gold moves a person closer to owning gold. A gold ETF cannot be used to purchase gold.

Storage Options for Physical Gold

Weighing costs and dangers are necessary to choose the optimal storage solution. Some people opt to keep their gold at home or their place of business because paying for secure storage reduces income from the metal's gains.

Theoretically, that is the riskiest choice because there is a greater chance of suffering losses from theft or natural disasters. However, these hazards are frequently not significant enough to warrant the price of other storage solutions. 

The metal can be kept in a depository or safe deposit box to reduce security hazards. Investors that do this should be aware that rates fluctuate, making it worthwhile to shop around.

Certain banks officially forbid the keeping of bullion is another thing to consider. This is stated in the terms and conditions that clients must sign.

Another thing to consider when choosing a financial organization for a safety deposit box is that not all security boxes are insured.

Final Words

Gold is still a well-liked investment option. It is seen as a haven that may be used to diversify your portfolio, and historically, it has maintained its value well during periods of economic turbulence. 

To make the best long-term investment decisions, investors should examine the benefits and drawbacks of physical gold vs. gold IRA, whether they're seeking to accumulate emergency funds or save enough money for retirement.

Gold could be a significant investment vehicle for those looking for a safe strategy to generate income from their investment portfolio without incurring many risks.

You can get a Free Gold Investors Guide from our top gold and precious metals company recommendation by clicking the link above or you can read our article of the top companies we reviewed this year:

>> CLICK HERE to read our list of the Top Gold IRA Companies. <<