Altier Rare Coins Review

Altier Rare Coins Review

Disclaimer: We are reader supported.  We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.

Altier Rare Coins was created by Justin Altier. Altier has worked across the U.S. purchasing rare coins and performing appraisals for his clients.

He has worked for several dealers, attended many trade shows, and has extensive knowledge regarding jewelry that has helped shape his successful business in buying and selling rare coins. 

Justin Altier has built a solid reputation in South Florida and is here to help collectors, investors, and anyone looking to buy or sell coins increase their profits.

Before we get started with this review:

We understand how difficult it is to pick a company that you can trust with your hard earned savings.  That's why we create informative and useful information to give you as much knowledge as possible to make the right decision.

We created a list of our highest recommended investment companies, to make comparing and choosing the company best suited to your needs as easy as possible.

Look to see if Altier Rare Coins was selected to our "highest recommendation" list this year!


Get a FREE Gold Investing Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:

gold ira investing information

Altier Rare Coins Products and Services

altier rare coins homepage

Much of Altier's business is focused on buying coins from its clients, while also performing estate appraisals. The company states that they buy bullion, currency, and jewelry.

  • Gold and Silver Bullion

The most common forms of bullion bars are made from gold, silver, and platinum. Bullion bars are an excellent option for investors who want to store the bars for a long time. 

Investors can also sell gold and silver precious metals rounds. Bullion rounds have a great design and are easy to liquidate, making them a good investment for everyone.

  • Rare and Collectible Currency

Altier Rare Coins is also a rare and collectible currency dealer. The company states that they are a leading buyer of United States Currency and one of the best currency obsolete currency dealers in South Florida.

  • Jewelry and Estate Buying

Altier Rare Coins also buys jewelry. If you have old jewelry laying around, Altier will take it off your hands. They purchase all types of jewelry from watches, bracelets, necklaces, and rings. 

The company's experienced appraisers will also help you maximize the value of each item in your estate. Altier focuses on giving your estate the best price to maximize your profits.

  • Coin Grading

Altier Rare Coins uses the Sheldon Scale when grading precious metals and rare coins. The scale comprises coins that range from poor to Perfect Mint State.

Coins are classified according to their current state. Coins may be given a condition, such as Excellent, Good, or Fair.

Selling to Altier Rare Coins

five bullion coins

Altier States that they serve in-house clients and mail-in clients. If you choose to mail in your items, they will be received and inspected at their South Florida office.

After inspecting your items for evaluation, one of their buyers will contact you by mail or by phone.  You will have 72 hours to accept or decline their purchase offer. If you accept the offer, your payment will be sent within 24 hours of you accepting it.

You can receive your payment as a check, bank wire, or PayPal.  If you don't like the offer, you are not obligated to accept it.

All you need to do is tell them that you would like your items returned, and Altier Rare Coins will schedule a return delivery with you and get your items back to you as quickly as possible.

The company states that you won't owe them anything and that they will pay for the return shipping.  The company highlights that company business checks are mailed the same day you accept your offer.

They will typically send checks via USPS first-class mail. If larger funds are involved, a bank wire will be arranged. Note that the wiring process can take up to 48 hours to show in your account. 

Paypal payments are sent electronically on the same day you accept your offer. Altier Rare Coins does not charge for this type of payment, but Paypal fees may apply.


Altier Rare Coins is an authorized dealer for PCGS, PMG, NGC, and CAC. The company has only a handful of reviews from customers, with 8 reviews on Trustpilot and 5 reviews on Yelp. 

The company averages a rating of 2.8 out of 5 on Trustpilot. Most reviewers stated that Justin was great to work with, knowledgeable about the industry, and offers fair prices. 

There appears to be only one negative review on Trustpilot regarding a timing discrepancy.

Google stated that the location closed at 4 p.m. but the store closed at 3 p.m. If you're near one of their locations, it's best to call and confirm their location hours before visiting. 

The company averages a 4 out of 5 on Yelp. Reviewers stated that Justin is honest and fair with pricing.

Reviewers also stated that the company is quick and responsive. Many of the reviewers consider Altier Rare Coins as their go-to financial company for precious metals.

Customer Service

If you have any questions or concerns, you can give the company a call at 954.580.3595. You can also email them at 

They also offer a frequently asked question section in the About category on their website. Altier Rare Coins provides information regarding your coin for quick solutions to some of their common questions.

Altier Rare Coins Pros

Altier Rare Coins appears to be a solid company, offering comprehensive services for investors. But before moving forward, it's essential to take a look at some of the pros and cons to help you make the best decision for your investment needs.

Here are a few pros and cons to consider:

  • Positive Reviews

Reviews play a vital role when it comes to finding the best precious metals dealer. While Altier Rare Coins hasn't built an extensive list of reviews, the company has garnered mostly positive reviews about its service. 

Most clients have stated that Justin was professional, knowledgeable, and transparent. Clients have also stated that the company offers a fair price for precious metals and most customers appeared to be overall satisfied with doing business with the company.

  • Authorized Dealer for Several Reputable Companies

Altier Rare Coins hasn't just racked up great reviews, the company is also an authorized dealer for several reputable companies, including CAC, NGC, and PCGS.

This helps to reinforce the idea that Altier Rare Coins is a reputable company and a solid choice when choosing a precious metals dealer for your investments.

  • The Company Buys Several Rare Coins

Another advantage of Altier Rare Coins is that the company buys several types of rare coins. For investors looking to turn their precious metals into cash, you'll be pleased with the metals that the company accepts. 

The company buys gold and silver bullion, gold and silver precious metal bullion rounds, gold and silver bullion coins, federal reserve notes, and more.

  • Coin Grading

Altier Rare Coins is quite transparent and honest in its offers. The company's coin grading feature makes it easy for investors to know how their coins are being graded when they're selling.

Altier Rare Coins states that their numismatist work on-site to grade and authenticate each coin before making an offer. 

On their website, you can find an extensive breakdown of how they go about grading, which is also useful in helping investors grade their own coins for comparison using their method.

  • No Fee if You Reject an Offer

For investors that are mailing in their coin, this pro is particularly great. Once you've received an offer, you're not obligated to accept it. Even more, you won't have to pay a fee to ship the item back to you if you decide you want your items returned. 

Altier Rare Coins claims that they will pay the cost of shipping on your behalf, which is a nice benefit for investors who want to keep their costs down.


  • No Gold IRA Account

For investors looking for a gold IRA, you won't find it with Altier Rare Coins. They strictly buy rare coins and metals from clients. If you're interested in opening a gold IRA account, this is something that you'll need to find with another financial institution.

  • No Option to Purchase Rare Coins

Investors can sell rare coins to Altier Rare Coins, but you won't have the option to buy precious metals or coins on the company's website. The company only buys. If you're interested in purchasing precious metals, you'll need to find a precious metals dealer.


Altier Rare Coins is a rare coin, precious metals, and estate appraisal company. They have built a solid reputation for being professional, knowledgeable, and transparent about their process and appraisals. 

The company is also an authorized dealer for several reputable companies, which helps support the idea that this is a trusted company to do business with.

Altier Rare Coins has a client-centric approach. They focus on providing clients with fair appraisals and fast delivery. 

If you're interested in opening a gold IRA account, Altier Rare Coins doesn't offer this service. Additionally, there's no option to purchase rare coins for your collection.

The company strictly buys rare coins and precious metals and performs estate appraisals for clients.  All in all, Altier Rare Coins appears to be a company worth giving a try.

With positive reviews and trust from reputable companies, this company is a great option for new and seasoned investors to turn their coins and precious metals into cash.

You can get a Free Gold Investors Guide from our top gold and precious metals company recommendation by clicking the link above or you can read our article of the top companies we reviewed this year:

>> CLICK HERE to read our list of the Top Gold Investing Companies. <<

Or, if you like what you have read about Altier Rare Coins, you can go to there website below: